| Character | |
| Phantom (EriK) | Austin Smith, Preston Yates |
| Christing Daee | Jennifer Neff, Lisa Zimmerman |
| Count de Chandon (Philippe) | Stephan Faulk, McKay Nicoll |
| Gerard Carriere | John Philpott, David Weekes |
| Alain Cholet | Patrick Kintz, B.J. Whimpey |
| La Carlotta | Mandi Barrus, Raina Thorne |
| Jean-Claude (Stage Manager) | Oran de Baritault, Zac Freeman |
| Inspector Ledoux | Abram Yarbro, Derrick Dean |
| Joseph Buquet/Actor/First Niter/Police | Clark Bullen, Keith Goodrich |
| Young Carriere/Actor/First Niter/Theatre Staff | Myles Woolstenhulme, McKay Elwood |
| Oberon/Waiter/Actor/First Niter/Theatre Staff | Gregory Harrison, Andrew Jeffries |
| Minister of Culture/Theatre Staff | Jeffrey Black, Jared Campbell |
| Head Waiter/First Niter/theatre Staff | Braden Rymer, Lucas Stewart |
| Waiter/First Niter/Theatre Staff/Police | Kaden Caldwell, Eric Lash |
| Waiter/First Niter/Theatre Staff/Police | David Hollerbach, Charlie Flint |
| Flora | Kyra Furman, Kailey Azure Green |
| Florence | Madison Hanson, Mailee Halpin |
| Fleure | Jennifer Aguirre, Reba Johnson |
| Opera Diva 1/First Niter/1st Soprano | Summer Alvey, Mindi Hansen |
| Opera Diva 2/First Niter/2nd Soprano | Jana Cox, Lauren Slagowski |
| Belladova/First Niter | Claire Milner, Mikaela Petrik |
| Ballerina 1/First Niter/Theatre Staff | Julianna Pearson, Brooke Storheim |
| Ballerina 2/First Niter/Theatre Staff | Lauren Huntsman, TBD |
| Ballerina 3/First Niter/Theatre Staff | Olivia Huntsman, Devree Roberts |
| Ballerina 4/First Niter/Theatre Staff | Brecke Swan, Abigail Smith |
| Young Erik | TBD |
