| Monday, Wednesday, Friday Cast | Character | Tuesday, Thursday, Saturday Cast |
| Keith Evans | Percy Blakeney | Daniel Beck |
| Amy Keeler | Marguerite St. Just | Erin Royall Carlson |
| Quinn Dietlein | Chauvelin | Dallyn Bayles |
| Alex Vaughn | Armand St. Just | Nathan Kremin |
| Morgan Western | Marie Grosholtz | Becca Burdick |
| Caleb Collier | Tussaud | Clayton Barney |
| Austin Smith | Ozzy | Jason Baldwin |
| Taylor Morris | Dewhurst | Doug Irey |
| Josh Richardson | Elton | David Glaittli |
| Sanford Porter | Farleigh | David Matthew Smith |
| Cameron Garner | Hal | Jacob Khalil |
| Brandan Ngo | Ben | Chase Petersen |
| Landon Horton | Montgomery Clark/St. Cyr | Abram Yarbro |
| John Nielsen | Bredesen | Colton Hattabaugh |
| Grant Whitmer | Mercier/Tenor | Kyle Fotheringham |
| Clark Bullen | Coupeau/Tenor | Christian Lackman |
| Anthony Lovato | Prince of Wales/Robespierre | Jeffrey Whitlock |
| Mark Fotheringham | Jessup | Jim Dale |
| Jerry Westberg | Man 1/Tenor | Mike Romney |
| Tanner Sumens | Man 2/Tenor | Charlie Flint |
| Ryan Crockett | Man 3/Tenor | Eric Lash |
| Holden Smith | Man 4/Tenor | Jadon Webster |
| Kelton Davis | Man 5/Bass | Bryan Johnson |
| Ardon Smith | Man 6/Bass | Christopher Curtis-Romijn |
| Ellora Lattin | Woman 1/Alto | Jaymie Inouye |
| Stacia Hardy | Woman 2/Soprano | Kendra Thomas |
| MacKenzie Pedersen | Woman 3/Soprano 2 | Amelia Rose Moore |
| Madison Hanson | Woman 4/Soprano | Reba Johnson |
| Keri Vance | Woman 5/Alto | Julie Waite |
| Raina Thorne | Woman 6/High C Soprano | Jennifer Aguirre |
